Foto: BB.LV / пешеходы
Some consider the initiative a necessary step to strengthen the position of the state language, while others see it as political populism and demand clarification on what specific restrictions are planned to be introduced. The discussion touched on the current language legislation, the freedom of private communication, and the possible consequences for Russian-speaking residents of the country. One of the main questions of the discussion was the lack of specifics in the government’s promise. A resident of Latvia, Matiss, doubted the necessity of additional restrictions, noting that many areas of Russian language use are already regulated by existing legislation. According to him, state institutions, public information, advertising, job announcements, and product labeling are already subject to the requirements of language legislation. “LOL… I AM for the Latvian language as the only state language and believe that everyone living in Latvia should know it. But what exactly does ‘restriction of the Russian language in public space’ mean? State institutions, service in Latvian? Absolutely! But if two people are speaking Russian in a park? Or a private company serves clients not only in Latvian but also in Russian? Where does the strengthening of the state language end and the limitation of people’s freedom begin? I would like specifics, not beautiful slogans. Populism.” The author of another publication, Davis, on the contrary, regarded the government’s promise as a positive signal. “In Latvia, there is one state language, and the others are foreign. Punishment for violations, if they are indeed violations, is also a normal thing, as it is the enforcement of the law,” he emphasized. However, Matiss urged not to rush to conclusions and to wait for specific proposals. “I am all for positive changes in any area. But at the same time, I am against extremes. Therefore, I will wait for some specifics, not populist phrases from our politicians,” he wrote. ## ## Where does the protection of the language end and the limitation of freedom begin? Some participants in the discussion supported the need for more consistent use of the Latvian language but expressed concerns about possible excesses. One commenter suggested that the initiative might be primarily aimed at the use of the Russian language in state institutions, advertising, and the media. As an example, he cited the situation with service at the Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs (PMLP), where, according to him, employees continued to respond to visitors in Russian. In response, Matiss questioned the practical possibility of total control over the use of other languages. “Does this mean that before entering the PMLP, we need to set up a control of people and check where they came from? Or should everyone who does not know Latvian come with translators? Install cameras and fine all employees who use any other language besides Latvian?” he wrote ironically. Later, the discussion also touched on the issue of everyday communication. Some participants feared that further restrictions could even affect children who speak Russian at home with their parents. One commenter called Latvia a “pseudo-democratic” country, stating that restricting people’s right to speak their native language is cruelty. “Children will suffer the most again. Go and explain to them why they cannot speak at school and on the street in the language their parents speak to them at home. It’s terrible, I can’t even imagine,” he wrote. In response, Matiss urged not to exaggerate the possible consequences of the initiative and again emphasized that so far it is only about a political promise, not a ready-made bill. “We need to separate extremism, populism, and reality here. We have extremists and populists. In reality, sometimes the attitude towards the use of the Russian language has indeed been too lenient — in schools, paperwork, and other areas. But now, in my subjective opinion, everything is already organized. Further restrictions are especially difficult. And I like how this issue is resolved in Estonia,” he noted. In response to another remark about possible bans for children, Matiss replied even more categorically: “You are exaggerating now That’s exactly what my post was about You cannot prohibit anything much more than what is already in place. And no new bill has been adopted or even developed yet. This is populism.” ## ## International Image of Latvia A separate part of the discussion touched on how Latvia’s language policy is perceived abroad. A user on the social network Threads, living in the UK, shared that his acquaintances sometimes ask about the alleged oppression of the Russian-speaking population in Latvia. In his opinion, loud political statements without clear explanations can create additional opportunities for Russian propaganda. “Our government should not give Putin’s propaganda additional reasons. Issues can be resolved legislatively, without loud populist slogans that can be used in the information war,” he noted. With this remark, Matiss partially agreed, adding that there is no need to fear Russian internet trolls, but the lack of clear information does indeed raise questions. “The fact that there is no clear, normal information is one hundred percent. I don’t like it either,” he wrote. At the same time, other participants in the discussion emphasized that the Russian language should not automatically become the language of communication in the Latvian public space. One participant recounted instances in the UK when interlocutors, upon learning of her origin from Latvia, automatically associated the country with Russia and the Russian language. “The Russian language should not be heard on every corner,” she emphasized.